Transition Guidance for Outgoing Faculty PIs
Tools for Outgoing Faculty PIs
Award Relinquishment or Transfers for Outgoing Faculty
When a faculty member who is serving as PI of a sponsored research award transfers to a new institution, Brown must determine whether the award will be relinquished, transferred or retained under a different PI. In all scenarios, the departing faculty member must complete certain closeout tasks relating to their awards, such as final report preparation and effort reporting before their departure.
If circumstances dictate that the PI’s sponsored research awards will be transferred to the PI’s new institution, it is important to review the sponsor’s written guidance, as the process for this type of action will vary by sponsor. The Division of Research provides award transfer process guidelines below for the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and National Science Foundation (NSF).
Equipment Transfers
If a departing faculty member intends to transfer equipment items to their new institution, certain approvals are required by University policy. Equipment is defined as tangible, nonexpendable, personal property having an anticipated useful life of one year or more and having a unit acquisition cost of $5,000 or greater.
When a PI transfers to another educational institution and wishes to transfer University or federally owned property, the PI must furnish a written request for approval to the department chairperson or senior University officer. The PI should fully justify the request and include a list of items to be transferred, obtained by physical inventory of the lab or office space. All property, regardless of value or original cost must be approved prior to transfer out of Brown.
A representative at the business office of the receiving institution must certify in writing that the institution is willing to accept responsibility for the property to be transferred. The department chairperson has the initial approval authority for the transfer of property. Additional approvals must then be obtained from Sponsored Projects and the Controller's Office. In addition, the external funding sponsor may need to authorize the University to transfer the property. Where title cannot be transferred, the University may be willing to loan property to enable the PI to carry on the research without interruption.
This guidance can be found in Brown’s Movable Equipment Manual, in the section “Transferring Property to Another Educational Institution.”
Transfer of Data and Materials
Outgoing faculty who intend to transfer data and/or tangible research materials (e.g., animal models, cell lines, specimens, plasmids, antibodies) to their new institution must contact Brown’s Research Agreements and Contracting (RAC) team. A RAC staff member will review the inventory and determine if an agreement or written permission is required before the data and/or materials are transferred to a new institution. RAC staff will draft the appropriate agreements and send them to the new institution for review and execution.
Data and materials that often require an agreement include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Data provided under a data use agreement
- Data collected at Brown or generated using Brown funds that include any of the following:
- Individually identifiable health information or protected health information (PHI)
- Personally identifiable information (PII)
- Student information derived from education records that are subject to the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA)
- Data that are controlled by laws or regulations other than or in addition to those listed above
- Data obtained from an individual or organization under obligations of confidentiality
- Data of which the storage, use and transfer must be controlled for other reasons (e.g., Risk Level 3 data, or data with proprietary concerns)
- Materials developed in the outgoing faculty’s lab while at Brown
- Materials developed by other faculty at Brown
- Materials developed using Brown funds
- Materials received from a third party under a material transfer agreement
- Materials purchased from a repository under a material transfer agreement or other terms of use such as Jackson Labs, American Type Culture Collection (ATCC), Addgene, etc.
Data and materials that require an agreement may not be transferred without a fully executed agreement. Please contact researchcontracts@brown.edu for more information.
Research Agreements and Contracting
The Research Agreements and Contracting (RAC) team is responsible for drafting, negotiating and managing contracts and agreements in support of research at Brown.
Human Subjects Research Options for Researchers Leaving Brown
Export-Controlled Equipment and Technical Data
Contact Brown’s Export Control team as early as possible in any of the following situations:
- If you have been on a Technology Control Plan (TCP) or other export compliance plan (Contact Export Control prior to leaving the institution to discuss the closeout of the control plan or transfer of the controlled technology, information, materials or item to another PI at Brown or to your new institution.)
- If you have any trainees from comprehensively embargoed countries who are staying at Brown but are transferring to a new supervisor/PI
- If you are leaving the University to go to a new institution outside the U.S. (The transfer or export of technology, hardware, materials, research tools or items to your new institution abroad may require an export license.)
Conflict of Interest
If you are on a conflict of interest management plan at Brown, prior to leaving the University, you should contact Brown’s Research Integrity team to discuss the plan’s closeout. If you are planning to transfer a grant under a management plan to your new institution, you should contact your new institution’s conflict of interest office.
Conflicts of interest that are managed in connection with research funded through the U.S. Public Health Service (including the NIH) or the U.S. Department of Energy require annual reporting to the federal sponsors. If you are transferring grants to your new institution, this reporting requirement will also transfer to your new institution.
After you have left Brown, if you continue to work as an investigator on a research grant at Brown through an adjunct or visiting appointment (not under a subcontract to your new institution), you will continue to be subject to Brown’s Conflict of Interest in Research Policy. Specifically this means that you will continue to have reporting and training obligations at Brown. Important information regarding conflict of interest reporting and training requirements will be communicated to your Brown email address. Please ensure that your Brown email is linked or will be forwarded to your new institution’s email.